救赎什么？灵魂？自由？信念？你看看这部电影就有体会了

看了十几集，迈开腿让我看看你的鲲吧觉得真可以，人人艺的演技不是盖的，后面据说有些寡淡，还没看不好评说，那京片子真地道，原雨让我动了心～就冲这！四星～

A cheap and reactionary film. There is no "redemption" here, but "hope" (the hope of what?). What happens the next day, when parole officers catch up with Red? What happens to bringing the real culprit of Andy's wife behind the bar? Where is the PTSD of an "institutional man?" There is no deep critique of prison economy here, nor that of America's CJS (all we have is a few corrupt officials outsmarted by a banker who of course ran away w all the money and is praised for it, sounds familiar?). The completely implausible "figaro" sequence cheapens the real struggle for freedom. All of this is the stuff of cheap Hollywood.

3.5，这是一部充满诗意迷离的片子，迈开腿让我看看你的鲲吧就像在低吟一首诗。看到结尾在墓地偶遇的黎明，才发现片名的含义。但剪成两小时会更好，三小时太长了。

我就说是美国片嘛，整部片子都是美国味儿！说回正题，片子剧情不错，但主角完美过头了属于非人类级别，削到四星。ps我从片子结尾看出了基味